I entered two beers in the National Homebrew Competition this year; an Imperial IPA I brewed on New Year's Day this year (New Years D'Ale), and a barleywine I brewed on MLK day 2007 (I.H.A.D. Barleywine). The IIPA was thoroughly panned (hey, I thought it was good), but the barleywine advanced to the final round by placing 2nd in the Northwest Region in Category 19. I entered it as an English Barleywine (even though I formulated it as an American BW).
Category 19 Strong Ale Sponsored by Northern Brewer
1 19b Michael Boos of Seattle, WA, Mountain Top Mashers [AZ]
2 19b Robert Ginn of Poulsbo, WA, West Sound Brewers
3 19c Mark Beck, Joe Germani of Walla Walla, WA, Blue Mountain Brewers Club
And here are a few stats from Cat 19 in the NW Region:
Max Score: 39 Min Score: 17 Avg Score: 31.3 # of Entries: 19
I scored 39, but since they use a mini-BOS to determine the winners the first place beer isn't necessarily the highest scoring entry. The barleywine had an OG right around 1.100 and didn't attenuate as well as I'd have liked. I think it stopped around 1.028. I bottled it and it never really carbonated to the level I wanted. Due to the higher than desired residual sugar the beer is a little more malt-forward than I was shooting for. That and the lower than desired carbonation level explain why it fits in the English category better than the American. In any event, it is aging well and was good enough to get past the first round. I don't expect much out of it in the finals, but I was surprised last year by how well my Tripel did, so who knows. Anything can happen. Here's the recipe, in both Promash .rec format and HTML: Promash | HTML